The mirror image rule is an established principle stating that for a contract to be valid and legally enforceable, the acceptance of the offer must exactly match the offer that is given. Traditional contract law requires that an offer and an acceptance to that. Under the ucc, an offeree may often create a contract even when the acceptance includes terms that are additional to or different from those in the offer clickwraps. The mirror image rule requires the offer to be accepted as is for a. At common law, the mirror image rule requires an acceptance to be exactly like the offer. Mirror image rule law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Rule mirror image rule an acceptance must be the mirror. The mirror image rule requires an acceptance to adhere exactly to an offer to create a contract. Sales law compared with commonlaw contracts and the cisg. The mirror image rule requires that the terms of an offerees acceptance must exactly match the terms of the offerors to form a valid contract. Mirror image rule law and legal definition the mirror image rule refers to a contract law principle that the acceptance must match the offer to form a contract. Prior to adoption of the uniform commercial code ucc, the common law mirror image rule held that an acceptance that did not precisely parrot the terms set out in the offer was never an acceptance but a mere counteroffer. The mirror image rule is a doctrine in contract law that provides that an offer by the offeror must be accepted exactly and without any modifications by the offeree in order for there to be an enforceable contract.
The change that the prides made in the contract is considered a counteroffer and therefore violates the mirror image rule. Acceptance general under the restatements mirror image. The reasoning behind the rule is that an offeror is the master of his own offer and. In the law of contracts, the mirror image rule, also referred to as an unequivocal and absolute acceptance requirement, states that an offer must be accepted exactly with no modifications. Mirror image rule comes under the common law of offer and acceptance. The common law mirror image rule requires acceptance on precisely the sane terms as the offer.
This is called the mirror image rule and it applies to contracts for services or land not. This is one area where common law contracts and ucc contracts differ. Some unilateral contracts do not require that an offeror be notified of acceptance. When someone extends a contract offer to another party, the power to create a contract is placed in the hands of the other party. When an acceptance contains additional terms, the ucc and the common law contain different rules.
If the offer is amended, there can be no acceptance. The mirror image rule is a principle in contract law which states that an acceptance to an offer cannot introduce new or changed terms. The mirror image rule is a traditional rule of contract law which requires an acceptance to contain the same terms as an offer, otherwise, there is no contract. Under common law prior to the uniform commercial code, the mirror image rule required that the buyers acceptance be a mirror image of the sellers offer. Mirror image rule acceptance must match the terms of the offer exactly under ucc a contract when the offerees response indicates a definite acceptance of the offer, even if the acceptance includes additional or different terms. A well established principle in contract law that a contract is only formed when the acceptance matches the offer exactly. Contract formation requires an offer and an acceptance plus consideration, but thats the subject for another day.
Mirror image rule wex us law lii legal information. How has the ucc changed the common laws mirror image rule, and why. Clickwrap and shrinkwrap agreements are generally enforceable. The mirror image rule requires the offer to be accepted as is for a contract to be formed. In the law of contracts, the mirror image rule, also referred to as an unequivocal and absolute acceptance requirement, states that an offer must be accepted. This lesson deals with the problem created by the battle of the forms. At common law, where the mirror image rule reigns, if the acceptance differs from the offer, no. A reply purporting to be an acceptance which does not reflect the terms of the offer constitutes a rejection and counteroffer. Understanding the roles of offer and acceptance in the. This rule states that the acceptance of an offer must be exactly as demanded by the offeror. In order for a contract to be formed, the parties must reach mutual assent also called a meeting of the minds.
Although historically the terms of the acceptance had to be the mirror image of the terms of the offer, the uniform commerical code provides that even modified terms of the offer in a definite expression of acceptance constitute a contract. An attempt to accept the offer on different terms instead creates a counteroffer, and this constitutes a rejection of the original offer. In recent years, the courts tend to apply the mirror image rule in a more liberal fashion. At common law, the mirror image rule required that the acceptance language mirror that of the offer. This is a major departure from the mirror image rule required by commonlaw contracts.
Mirror image rule incomplete ambiguous agreements the essential core of the agreement. Which of the following statements about the mirror. Mirror image rule acceptance must match the terms of the. B says she accepts the offer but also wants the car to come with a big red ribbon on the hood. This classical approach to contract formation has been modified by developments in the law of estoppel, misleading conduct, misrepresentation, unjust enrichment, and power of acceptance.
Offer and acceptance analysis is a traditional approach in contract law. Mirror image rule applies only under the common law acceptance terms must match offer terms exactly, or no agreement no addition deletions, or modifications in acceptance are allowed under the common law ucc allows different terms in an acceptance, unless the offeror prohibits them as part of the offer. A contract generally comes into existence and becomes binding at the moment the parties have reached an agreement on all material provisions, although they may intend to later write down the terms of. Once an offer is accepted, the parties have a legal agreement. The common law rule requires that acceptance be the mirror image of the offer. If someone responds to accept an offer but adds in new terms, it becomes a rejection and counteroffer, and the original offer is no longer binding. The mirror image rule requires that the acceptance exactly match the offer. Mirror image rule and ucc the common law mirror image rule.
Different or additional terms in the acceptance the battle of the forms under cisg. Match the terms in the offer mirror image rule terms in the acceptance must exactly match those in the offer, otherwise it is a counteroffer realty and services sale of goods if contract doesnt specifically say acceptance must exactly match terms in offer. Understanding the mirror image rule business zeal buzzle. The mirror image rule requires an acceptance to adhere exactly to an offer to create a contract true the agreement resulting from a buyer clicking on a box containing the words i agree is. This song deals with the issues of acceptance of contract offers. Just as the law helps define and shape an offer and its duration, so the law governs the. Acceptance generalunder the restatements mirror image rule restatement rule requiring the offerees acceptance not change the offer in any way, the offerees acceptance of an offer must be unequivocal and be a mirror image of the offer. The uniform commercial code ucc relaxes the common law mirror image rule if the merchants are dealing with goods. The mirror image rule requires that the terms in the acceptance must be close to the terms contained in the offer, true or false. Battle of the forms explained using a few short words. Keep in mind that acceptance follows the mirror image rule, in that acceptance is valid if the product or service rendered is exactly what was contained in the offer. Under this rule, if the offer is not accepted exactly as given, it constitutes a counteroffer, and the contract is.
The ucc requires application of the mirror image rule in cases where contracts for the sale of goods are made by exchanging forms. An offer is a definite statement of the offerors willingness to be bound should certain conditions be met. If the acceptance is not a mirror image of the offer, it is considered a rejection and a counteroffer that can be accepted by the original offeror. Every enforceable contract consists of three basic elements. New or additional terms included in an offer will become part of the contract on acceptance. The mirror image rule is the requirement that the offeree must accept all of. The rule is reversed under the uniform commercial code, however. This is typically reached through offer and an acceptance which does not vary the offers terms, which is known as the mirror image rule. The mirror image rule does not require an acceptance to match an offer to create a contract to create a contract f. The common laws mirror image rule makes the acceptance ineffective, and no contract is formed. If the party accepts the offer but changes one term, a contract does not exist under the mirror image rule. The mirror image rule requires that the terms of the.
This means that this rule does not apply in case of commercial transactions. Study 20 terms business law chapter 9 quiz truefalse. Cali the center for computerassisted legal instruction. Requires that acceptance be on precisely the same terms as the offer. The ucc rejects the common law mirror image rule in some circumstances. Common law and uniform commercial code contracts work. Even under the mirror image rule, no rejection is implied if an offereee merely asks about. Lewis had no legal duty to act or explicitly reject the counteroffer. Multiple choice no rejection is implied if an offeree merely asks about the terms of the offer without indicating its rejection. Courts in some states apply the mirror image rule only when the term in the offer is material. The mirror image rule requires that the terms of the acceptance exactly match the terms of the offer. If the offeree adds new terms to the acceptance, it is not really an acceptance. See also note 8 of the honnold book at 195 where he reports the. A bilateral acceptance occurs when an offeree indicated acceptance by performing his or her obligations under the contract, true or false.
For an acceptance to be valid, it generally must be identical to the offer. Under the common law, the mirror image rule means that an acceptance that adds to or contradicts an offer is generally considered a. The mirror image rule requires that the terms in the acceptance must be close to those in the offer. The mirror image rule refers to a contract law principle that the acceptance must match the offer to form a contract. The prides erroneously assumed that silence was equivalent to acceptance.
For the ucc, the primary issue is whether the parties intended to enter into a binding agreement. The offerees notification to the offeror that the offeree agrees to be bound by the terms of the offerors proposal. Therefore, under the mirror image rule, it was not an acceptance, it was a. The common law rule requires that acceptance be the mirror. Business law offer and acceptance warren hills regional. Mirror image rule applies only under the common law. The mirror image rule requires that the terms of the acceptance exactly match the terms of.
Thus, at least historically, any acceptance had to embrace the pricing and other information included in an offer, or there would be no binding contract. The mirror image rule is used throughout the business environment and is based on the requirement for an absolute and unequivocal acceptance to an offer to create a contract, with anything less than that. The manufacturer responded by telegram that it could not book the order at that price. Common law follows the mirror image rule, which means a legally recognized acceptance must be an exact mirror image of the terms of the offer. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The mirror image rule requires that the terms of t. In contract law, a doctrine requiring any acceptance to be an unconditional assent to the terms of the offer. The offer and acceptance formula, developed in the 19th century, identifies a moment of formation when the parties are of one mind. The restatement proposes the mirrorimage rule for acceptance of an offer. In a bilateral contract, communication of acceptance is necessary. Under common law rules, if an acceptance contains different terms, it is a. This rigid requirement led to an unfortunate practice whereby commercial dealings too often degenerated into a. The common law mirror image rule tells us that to form a contract the terms of the acceptance should match the terms of the offer.
769 1120 1219 464 978 715 1250 256 14 406 1488 401 665 235 809 1474 1128 10 680 445 505 1259 371 1066 911 296 75 1210 617 546 489 229 1320 1126 1174 474 521